Why EU minimum wage is really bad

Why EU minimum wage is really bad

The EU can only just work in those places where its user nations have authorised it to take action, through the EU treaties.

With regards to labour market policy, the treaty is quite clear. Pay, the best of relationship, the best to strike and also the straight to lock-out aren’t problems where in actuality the EU can act. Any make an effort to circumvent this could probably, and rightfully, be contested and brought ahead of the European Court of Justice.

Select your plan



Affordable option — only 50 cents on a daily basis

Reduced yearly

Pupil or resigned? Then this course of action is for you personally.

. Or join as a bunch

Remain informed in uncertain times

If you would like understand what’s occurring in European countries today, separate and information that is objective important.

Today why join?

View our editor-in-chief Koert Debeuf give an explanation for reasons in this 30-second movie.

Currently a part?

A concern of broad and present interest is the latest EU Commission president Ursula von der Leyen’s announced effort on presenting an EU legal tool on the absolute minimum wage inside the very first 100 times of her duration in workplace.

The accountable commissioner, Nicolas Schmit, has established that a primary outline may be posted on Tuesday (January 14th. )

Due to the fact president of 1 of this trade union confederations that are largest into the EU, I look at importance of good working conditions and decent pay in every user states. A lot of in European countries come in precarious jobs with low or incomes that are unstable.

The realisation associated with market that is internal never ever induce a competition towards the base where employees stay against employees. We are in need of a Personal Europe.

This need, nevertheless, does not always mean that individuals must embrace all proposals for labour market regulation from the level that is european even if the reported aim is laudable.

You will find few areas where the institutions vary the maximum amount of between your user states once the labour market.

The respective functions regarding the state together with social partners differ, as does the mix between legislation and bargaining that is collective manage such problems as wages, working some time work protection.

Regulation this is certainly key within one nation may be non-existent an additional.

The unionisation price one of the user states differs between not as much as five % to significantly more than 65 per cent.

This will make EU that are common of this labour market difficult and delicate.

In a recently available research of collective bargaining, the organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) makes a spot of exactly how even minor alterations in labour market policies can cause major and frequently unintended changes in bargaining behavior and industrial relations systems.

A binding instrument that is EU legal minimal wages or collective bargaining may have exactly this impact.

By obliging the user states up to a minimal wage on a particular degree or determined based on a particular formula, it could effortlessly force all EU nations to own either a statutory minimum wage or a method for expanding collective agreements to any or all employees inside a sector.

There are good reasons why you should doubt the likelihood to carve away exemptions or build firewalls to safeguard member states that do not have minimum that is statutory or the alternative to increase collective agreements, such how does chatki work as for instance Denmark, Italy and Sweden.

Through the Laval case concerning posted employees we all know very very first hand just exactly how effortlessly such claims could be brushed apart because of the Court of Justice.

But in addition nations which have minimum wage legislation or even the possibility to help make collective agreements generally binding have reasons why you should fret.

One must perhaps maybe not underestimate the fantastic problems connected with constructing a significant eu minimum wage directive.

The thought of ‘wages’ is definately not homogenous across user states, why a musical instrument geared towards harmonising the cheapest prices of pay would need to be incredibly detailed to be significant.

Otherwise, it should be simple to circumvent by either companies or government that is national.

First and foremost nonetheless, is that the EU lacks legal competence in the region of wages.

This article regarding the treaty that offers the EU legislative abilities in the field of labour market policy (Article 153) explicitly states that this doesn’t use to pay for, just the right of association, the ability to strike or perhaps the directly to impose lock-outs.

What rises, might drop

Accepting that EU has legislative abilities in the region of wages would place us on a dangerous course. This time around, it might be used to boost the cheapest quantities of pay.

The time that is next in a recession or economic crisis, it might be used to lessen wages. Yet later on, the freedom of relationship while the straight to strike could come under assault.

Consequently, any try to legislate in this area needs to be resisted plus in the conclusion be challenged within the Court of Justice.

Well-functioning systems for collective agreements just can’t be purchased from Brussels.

The necessity for an even more social Europe may not be met by legislation that operates the possibility of destroying well-functioning nationwide systems for commercial relations and bargaining that is collective.

As opposed to proposing an EU minimum wage contrary to the treaty, the payment should place more effort into supporting, although not regulating, the introduction of social discussion, collective bargaining and much more inclusive labour market policies within the user states.

The pillar of Social Rights and its non-binding nature and mechanisms for mutual learning is a good instrument to build on in this respect.

Author bio

Therese Svanstrom is president associated with the Confederation that is swedish of Employees (TCO), which comprises comprises 13 affiliated trade unions with over 1.4 million people.


The views expressed in this viewpoint piece would be the writer’s, maybe not those of EUobserver.

, your account provides you with use of most of our tales. We very appreciate your value and support your feedback. We would love to hear it if you have any thoughts on this story.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *